Romney’s Plan Would Increase Uninsured To 72 million In 2022; ACA Would Decrease Uninsured To 27 million: Commonwealth Fund

The number of uninsured individuals is estimated to increase to 72 million nationwide—with children and low- and middle-income Americans particularly hard hit—under Governor Mitt Romney’s plan to repeal the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) and replace it with block grants to states for Medicaid and new tax incentives, according to a recent Commonwealth Fund report entitled, Health Care in the 2012 Presidential Election: How the Obama and Romney Plans Stack Up. While the details of Governor Romney’s proposals have not been specified, a set of assumptions was made for the report based on similar proposals advanced in the past.

The report analyzes each candidate’s plan to address the U.S. health care system’s problems and estimates the resulting number of uninsured by age and income level in every state. The comparison relies on results of microsimulation analysis of the candidates’ plans conducted by economist Jonathan Gruber, who modeled the effects of the ACA, as opposed to repeal of the law and replacement with two Romney proposals: providing states with Medicaid block grants and new tax incentives to purchase individual coverage.

President Obama has identified near-universal health coverage as a goal, and his plan to continue to implement the ACA will reduce the number of uninsured nationwide, according to the Commonwealth Fund. Romney has said he would repeal the ACA; change Medicaid to a block grant program; use tax incentives to encourage people to buy individual health plans; and introduce more private plans to Medicare while providing beneficiaries with a specified sum of money, adjusted for health and income, to buy the plan they choose.

The report is framed around how the candidates’ plans perform on seven key issues: health insurance coverage, insurance affordability, consumer protection, consumer choice, help for small business, improving Medicare, and improving health care quality and slowing spending growth. On these seven questions, “The ACA would likely outperform Romney’s plan to repeal the law and replace it with fewer federal requirements and funding in insurance markets and the Medicaid and Medicare programs,” the report concluded.

“There are stark differences between what each candidate has proposed for our health care system, and this report shines a light on how Americans might be affected, based on their age, their income, and where they live,” said Sara Collins, vice president for affordable health insurance at The Commonwealth Fund. “The report finds that repealing the ACA would significantly increase the number of Americans without health insurance, limiting their ability to get the health care they need and exposing them to burdensome medical bills and debt.”

Impact estimates on children, middle-income families. The report finds that 17.9 million children under age 19 are estimated to be uninsured by 2022 under Romney’s plan, compared with an estimated 6 million under President Barack Obama’s plan to implement the ACA. In addition, under Romney’s plan, 17.7 million middle-income Americans—those with incomes between about $32,000 and $58,000 a year for a family of four—are estimated to be uninsured by 2022, or more than one-third of this income group. By comparison, 3.3 million middle-income families are estimated to be uninsured under the ACA. Among families with incomes under $32,000 a year for a family of four, 38.7 million people are estimated to be uninsured under Romney’s plan and 17.2 million under the ACA.

The report also found that young adults and baby boomers would have better access to secure health insurance coverage under the ACA, with an estimated 7.2 million young adults ages 19 to 29 remaining uninsured in 2022, compared with more than 18.6 million estimated to be uninsured under Romney’s plan. Among older adults ages 50 to 64, 4.9 million are estimated to be uninsured in 2022 under the ACA, while nearly 11.8 million would be uninsured under Romney’s plan.

Medicare. The Commonwealth Fund report finds significant differences in each candidate’s treatment of Medicare. Romney’s commitment to repealing the ACA would eliminate the phasing out of the “doughnut hole” in the prescription drug benefit, beneficiaries’ free annual wellness visit, and preventive care with no cost-sharing. Romney’s plan also would eliminate an estimated $716 billion in cost savings and, over time, raise the Medicare eligibility age to 67. Converting Medicare to a premium support program, as Romney has proposed, might raise beneficiaries’ out-of-pocket costs if the premium allowances failed to keep pace with health care cost growth. In addition, without the ACA’s provisions, the Medicare Hospital Insurance Trust Fund would be depleted by 2016, rather than 2024, as currently projected under the ACA.

The report noted the following additional differences between the candidates’ plans:

Affordable health insurance: Under the ACA, people buying individual plans through health insurance exchanges or the individual market would spend an average of 9.1 percent of their incomes on premiums and out-of-pocket costs, compared with 18.1 percent in the absence of the ACA. If Romney’s proposal to equalize the tax treatment of individual and employer-based plans were accomplished by offering an income tax deduction for people who purchase individual health insurance, those buying individual plans would spend an average of 14.1 percent of their income on premiums and out-of-pocket costs.
Consumer protections: The ACA imposes sweeping new rules on insurers to protect consumers in the health care marketplace. Some of these rules have already been implemented, including a ban on rescissions (insurers cancelling coverage when a beneficiary gets sick), bans on lifetime benefits, a phased-in ban on annual benefit limits, no longer allowing insurers to turn away children with preexisting conditions, and requiring insurers to cover preventive care without copayments from beneficiaries. Starting in 2014, insurers will no longer be able to deny or restrict coverage, or charge higher premiums, based on preexisting health conditions. Romney’s plan to repeal the ACA would rescind all of these protections. Romney has said that he would prevent discrimination against people with preexisting conditions who maintain continuous coverage.
Small business: Under the ACA, small businesses with low-wage workforces of fewer than 25 employees are eligible for tax credits to offset health insurance premium costs. About 170,000 small-business owners claimed the credits in 2010, and the President Obama has proposed increasing the eligibility to include businesses with up to 50 employees. Under Romney’s plan, small businesses currently eligible for the tax credits would lose them. Romney has proposed encouraging small businesses to form purchasing pools to buy health insurance.
Health care costs: A Congressional Budget Office analysis has determined that repealing the ACA would increase the federal deficit by $109 billion between 2013 and 2022, as new federal spending reductions and revenues in the Medicare program and other areas under the law would be lost along with the coverage expansions. Romney would replace these spending reductions and revenues by reducing federal funding to states for their Medicaid programs and in Medicare through the new premium support program.

“The ACA has, since its passage in 2010, already provided millions of Americans with access to more secure insurance coverage and needed health care,” said Karen Davis, Commonwealth Fund president. “It is critical that state and federal policymakers continue to work to put us on a path to achieving a high performance health care system that guarantees near-universal, affordable, and comprehensive health insurance coverage, and a health care system that provides high-quality, safe care.”

For more information, visit http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Publications/Fund-Reports/2012/Oct/Health-Care-in-the-2012-Presidential-Election.aspx.

Visit our News Library to read more news stories.